Do Fidget Spinners Help Kids Pay Attention in Class?

Do Fidget Spinners Help Kids Pay Attention in Class?

By Megan Smith & Yana Weinstein

Image from Flickr, Ryan Dickey

Image from Flickr, Ryan Dickey

Right now, fidget spinners are all the rage. They’ve become so popular that they became a topic of discussion on my (Megan’s) local Rhode Island radio station that I listen to during my commutes, Lite Rock 105. Amy Pontes (@amyliterock105) brought them up because of their increasing popularity. She noted people have even been selling them out of the trunks of their cars! Recently, her daughter was desperate to join the craze, and Amy bought one for the daughter’s 10th birthday. Why was Amy discussing this on the radio? Well, after purchasing the fidget spinner for her daughter, Amy was surprised to learn that the use of fidget spinners isn’t backed by science. I immediately had two thoughts. 

First, kudos to Lite Rock 105 for caring about the science! (In fact, this radio station often discusses science as it applies to regular listeners, and it’s one of the reasons I love them.)

Second, what claims are the companies selling fidget spinners making about these little gadgets? Is there some type of false advertising is going on? Or, are they relying upon research that doesn’t directly examine fidget spinners to make claims that overreach? What do other experts say?

What is a fidget spinner?

These small toys work using ball bearings. In their simplest form, kids can hold them between their fingers and let them spin. However, a search on YouTube will quickly show you how much some kids really can do with these things. Here is a video full of kids doing fidget spinner tricks. It was posted less than 3 weeks ago, and it already has over half a million views. These tricks are somewhat reminiscent of yo-yo tricks from our elementary school days.

What claims are companies making?

These little toys are marketed as ways to help students with ADHD focus, and as a way for anxious children to relieve stress. The claim is that the spinners give students with ADHD something to do with their hands that can improve focus, and that they help anxious kids focus “nervous energy”. Some claim that fidget spinners can have health benefits such as easing stress or even post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). These companies on Amazon explicitly state the fidget spinners help with a number of such issues:

Image from this page

Image from this page

Screenshot from this page

Screenshot from this page

The popular media is getting involved, too. For example, one article from The National states:

“The spinner has also proved to be a valuable tool for those who work with special-needs students.”

Another article from CNN quotes Elaine Taylor-Klaus, co-founder of ImpactADHD:

“Promoting fidgeting is a common method for managing attention regulation… for some people [with ADHD], there’s a need for constant stimulation. What a fidget allows some people – not all people – with ADHD to do is to focus their attention on what they want to focus on, because there’s sort of a background motion that’s occupying that need.”

What does the science say?

Despite their rise in popularity, there does not seem to be solid scientific evidence that these toys help with attention issues. For example, Scott Kollins stated in a recent NPR article:

“I know there’s lots of similar toys, just like there’s lots of other games and products marketed towards individuals who have ADHD, and there’s basically no scientific evidence that those things work across the board.”

Kollins notes that because there’s such a large number of children with ADHD, and a lot of parents are searching for help, it makes them vulnerable to marketing ploys like the fidget spinners.

We tried to look for evidence that fidget spinners really do help learning. But what we found was scientists talking about how the spinners could help in theory – but no empirical studies to back up these assertions (a search for “fidget spinners” and “ADHD” on Google Scholar yielded one hit: an unpublished honors thesis).

In fact, sensory treatments – which include the use of gadgets such as fidget spinners – do not appear to be consistently effective for treating disabilities (1); although occupational therapists do now frequently suggest this type of treatment, the science appears to lag behind in terms of evidence of effectiveness (2).

Should you ban these from your home or classroom?

Toy fads like the fidget spinner are not new.  For example, this article notes that the rapid popularity, media attention, and concerns over the fidget spinners are similar to historical toy fads (e.g., the hula hoop). We searched to see if toys like the hula hoop or the yo-yo were ever passed off as toys to help students focus and learn, and we found some interesting things. For example, this article suggests that non-neurotypical children learn to hula hoop because it is an activity that they can do with others, and could promote social skills among these kids. This advice isn’t special to the hula hoop itself and is more about interaction with other kids than about the toy creating more focus in school. We didn’t, however, find huge advertisements claiming the hula hoop or the yo-yo helped kids focus. If they were proposed as tools to help children with ADHD, anxiety, stress, or focus, it at least wasn’t a prominent selling point of the toys. (If anyone has evidence to the contrary, please leave a comment!)

As with any fad, there are probably pros and cons to these. For example, Amy Pontes (from the Radio) noted that she liked that her daughter was playing with her fidget spinner with her friends rather than spending a ton of time on screens. Some teachers have even used these to their advantage in their science classes to demonstrate principles of physics, like friction and the use of ball bearings to reduce friction. See also this article on the physics behind fidget spinners.

However, some teachers have noted that these toys are more of a disruption in the classroom because they make noise and pull students’ attention away from the content.  Some schools in Minnesota and Massachusetts have actually banned them:

(View the video below, or click this link)

There are other issues as well. For example, some have pointed to the fidget spinner fad and made ties to disability discrimination. Many are upset about how popular they have become among neurotypical kids.

Bottom Line: For children with ADHD and Autism, these fidget spinners MAY help (at least some kids). However, we should be cautious while we wait for research to test fidget spinners empirically. Future research should also investigate when these might work to alleviate attention symptoms and when they may not. For the average student, we simply don’t have any scientific evidence to back claims that they help focus attention. Though, like with any fad, teachers may be able to turn fidget spinners into positive learning opportunities, and promote social play among children.


References:

(1) Barton, E. E., Reichow, B., Schnitz, A., Smith, I. C., & Sherlock, D. (2015). A systematic review of sensory-based treatments for children with disabilities. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 37, 64-80.

(2) Zimmer, M., Desch, L., Rosen, L. D., Bailey, M. L., Becker, D., Culbert, T. P., ... & Adams, R. C. (2012). Sensory integration therapies for children with developmental and behavioral disorders. Pediatrics, 129, 1186-1189.

Weekly Digest #62: Digital Literacy: A Crucial Skill in Today’s World

Weekly Digest #62: Digital Literacy: A Crucial Skill in Today’s World

GUEST POST: Two Examples Are Better Than One

GUEST POST: Two Examples Are Better Than One